When you're buying or selling a home, likely the largest financial transaction of your life, you naturally place enormous trust in your real estate lawyer.
After all, they're licensed professionals bound by strict ethical codes, right? Unfortunately, recent cases across Ontario reveal a disturbing pattern of real estate lawyers betraying that trust in the most devastating ways possible. It's important to understand that most lawyers are outstanding, ethical and responsible professionals, however, like every industry, there are a few "bad apples" that can create doubt and anxiety.
How Real Estate Lawyers Handle Your Money (And Where Things Can Go Wrong)
To understand how these frauds occur, it's crucial to know how real estate lawyers handle your money during transactions.
When you buy or sell a property, or refinance your mortgage, your lawyer doesn't just provide legal advice, they also act as a financial intermediary, holding your funds in what's called a "trust account."
Here's how it typically works: When you're buying a home, you transfer your down payment, mortgage funds, and other costs to your lawyer's trust account. Similarly, when selling, the buyer's funds flow through your lawyer's trust account before being distributed to pay off your mortgage, real estate fees, and hand you the remaining proceeds.
This system requires enormous trust because your real estate lawyer temporarily controls vast sums of money, often your life savings or the proceeds from your biggest asset. The trust account is supposed to be sacred, legally separate from the lawyer's personal and business funds, and used only for client transactions.
But as the cases below demonstrate, few lawyers can potentially exploit this system, treating client trust accounts like their personal piggy banks. The sophisticated nature of these frauds often means victims don't discover the theft until it's too late, sometimes months after they thought their transaction was complete.
The Staggering Scale of the Problem
The numbers are jaw-dropping. More than 200 Canadian lawyers who were disciplined between 2010 and 2015 misappropriated about $160 million of their clients' funds, according to a comprehensive CBC investigation. In Ontario alone, 71 lawyers were disciplined for taking money from their clients between 2010 and 2015, with consequences ranging from suspensions to complete disbarment.
But these aren't just historical problems. They're happening right now, affecting ordinary Ontarians who thought they could trust their real estate lawyer.
The Cartel & Bui Case: A $7 Million Nightmare
One of the most shocking recent cases involves Toronto lawyers Nicholas Cartel and Singa Bui, whose firm has been shut down, lenders have moved to seize their family homes, and they're facing 15 lawsuits and a police investigation after millions of dollars in client money went missing from the firm's trust accounts.
The scope of their alleged fraud is breathtaking. More than $7 million of their clients' money was stolen and funnelled into luxury purchases, including 58 pairs of Manolo Blahniks among hundreds of items seized at lawyer couple's home during the police investigation.
What makes this case particularly alarming is how long it continued unchecked. Despite complaints of financial irregularities at the firm going back to April 2023, a law society investigator only took steps to audit its bank accounts in late November. During that seven-month span, at least 10 people retained the firm for real estate transactions and transferred money to it; millions of dollars of that money went missing.
The couple's fraudulent scheme was sophisticated, involving what investigators described as a Ponzi-like operation. Initially, the shortfalls were covered by new money coming in, but starting in February 2023, payouts to clients of their proceeds from real estate deals began to stall. When questioned about the missing funds, "Although they must know what happened to the funds, they have refused to provide this information," Ontario Superior Court Justice William Chalmers ruled, finding both lawyers in contempt of court.
The Ping-Teng Tan Scandal: Retirement Dreams Destroyed
Another devastating case involves retired Toronto lawyer Ping-Teng Tan, who has been charged with fraud in the wake of allegations from clients that he kept their money. The impact on his victims has been life-altering.
Xiaolong Zhang and his wife hired Tan to handle the sale of their auto parts business to fund their retirement. Instead of receiving their $517,000 in proceeds they were owed from the sale — which was paid to a trust account set up by Tan's law firm, they've been left with nothing. "Now instead of enjoying our retirement, my wife and I are facing serious financial and emotional stress," said Zhang.
Even more troubling, Tan is also facing two lawsuits from clients who claim he kept proceeds from two real estate transactions, with courts ordering him to pay more than $1 million to various clients—money they still haven't received.
The psychological impact extends beyond financial loss. As Zhang explained, "If I encounter this kind of lawyer again, my life is gone because the house is worth more than double, triple of half million. If someone steals that money, what am I going to do for the rest of my life?"
Can I Trust my Real Estate Lawyer? Red Flags Every Homeowner Should Know
Given these alarming cases, how can you protect yourself when choosing and working with a real estate lawyer? Here are crucial warning signs:
Communication Red Flags:
- Delays in returning calls or providing updates about your transaction
- Vague explanations about where your money is being held
- Pressure to complete transactions quickly without proper documentation
- Reluctance to provide detailed accounting of trust fund activity
Transaction Red Flags:
- Requests to wire money to personal accounts rather than trust accounts
- Last-minute changes to closing procedures or fund transfers
- Unusual delays in receiving proceeds from sales
- Lawyer seems to be living beyond their apparent means
Documentation Issues:
- Incomplete or missing paperwork
- Reluctance to provide copies of all documents
- Trust account statements that don't match expected amounts
What Happens if You are a Victim of Fraud?
Ontario does have some safeguards in place, but they're not foolproof. The Law Society of Ontario operates a Compensation Fund that helps clients who have lost money because of a lawyer or paralegal's dishonesty. However, this fund has a $500,000 cap per claim, which may not cover major losses in today's real estate market.
According to the CBC, the fund also denied 30 claims involving lawyers and received 69 new claims concerning lawyers in 2024, showing that not all victims receive compensation.
Protecting Yourself in Real Estate Transactions
While these cases are alarming, there are steps you can take to minimize your risk:
- Research Your Lawyer: Check their standing with the Law Society of Ontario and look for any disciplinary history.
- Understand Trust Accounts: Ensure your lawyer uses proper trust accounts and provides regular statements showing your funds.
- Ask Questions: Don't hesitate to ask detailed questions about where your money is, when it will be transferred, and what safeguards are in place.
- Get Title Insurance: This can provide additional protection against fraud, though it won't cover all scenarios.
- Monitor Transactions: Stay involved in your transaction and ask for documentation at every step.
- Trust Your Instincts: If something feels wrong, investigate further or consider switching lawyers.
The Bottom Line
The question "Can I trust my real estate lawyer?" unfortunately doesn't have a simple answer. While the vast majority of real estate lawyers are honest professionals and they are overseen and regularly audited by regulators such as the LSO, the cases of Cartel & Bui, Ping-Teng Tan, and others show that some are willing to steal millions from the very clients they're supposed to protect.
The financial and emotional devastation these frauds cause, from destroyed retirement plans to lost family homes, underscores why vigilance is essential. In an industry where lawyers handle hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars in a single transaction, the potential for abuse is enormous.
As homebuyers and sellers, we must remain alert, ask hard questions, and never assume that professional credentials guarantee honest behavior. Your real estate lawyer holds tremendous power over your financial future. Make sure they're worthy of that trust.
A Modern Solution: Deeded's Revolutionary Approach
The cases outlined here serve as a stark reminder of the vulnerabilities in traditional real estate transactions. At Deeded, we're pioneering a new approach that fundamentally changes how real estate transactions work, putting power and control back in the hands of buyers and sellers.
Our platform leverages cutting-edge technology to create transparency and accountability that simply doesn't exist in the traditional lawyer-mediated system. By streamlining the transaction process and reducing the points where funds can be misappropriated.
In real estate transactions, trust must be earned. Your financial security may depend on it. Or better yet, choose a system where trust isn't required because transparency is built in from the ground up.
If you suspect your real estate lawyer has misappropriated funds, contact the Law Society of Ontario immediately at 1-800-268-8326 and consider filing a police report. The sooner you act, the better your chances of recovering stolen funds.
Unlock Your Seamless Closing Experience
Your Journey to a Worry-Free Closing Starts Here!
